Viva Los Vanquished Toronto Blue Jays
Who won the most games against the Toronto Blue Jays?
Back to Excruciating Baseball Lists
| Overall records | ||||||||||||||
| ANA | ARI | ATL | BAL | BOS | CHA | CHN | CIN | CLE | COL | DET | FLO | HOU | KCA | LAN |
| MIL | MIN | NYA | NYN | OAK | PHI | PIT | SDN | SEA | SFN | SLN | TBA | TEX | TOR | WAS |
Most wins, career
25 Mike Mussina (6/7/19929/23/2008
24 Roger Clemens (6/22/19848/7/2007
21 Andy Pettitte (9/19/19957/3/2010
17 Mike Flanagan (9/14/1977[g1]8/11/1986
17 Tim Wakefield (8/5/19965/19/2009
16 Jamie Moyer (4/8/19896/27/2010
15 Kenny Rogers (4/9/19894/18/2008
14 Randy Johnson (7/23/19894/29/2006
14 Mike Moore (6/21/19828/6/1994
14 Jack Morris (5/28/19799/28/1991
14 Bob Stanley (7/7/19774/12/1987
13 Tom Gordon (4/5/19897/24/2003
13 Dennis Martinez (6/17/19777/24/1996
13 Scott McGregor (9/9/19788/2/1986
12 Dennis Eckersley (7/8/19777/8/1995[g2]
12 Bobby Witt (4/22/19866/27/1999
11 Buddy Black (7/19/19835/2/1990
11 Jon Garland (5/28/20017/6/2008
11 Ron Guidry (9/25/1977[g1]6/30/1987
11 Larry Gura (5/1/19777/13/1983
11 Moose Haas (5/2/19775/27/1987
11 Brad Radke (5/16/19968/13/2006
11 Jim Slaton (5/19/19775/1/1986
Most wins, relief
10 Bob Stanley (9/29/19776/30/1986
7 Tippy Martinez (9/3/1979[g1]4/13/1985
7 Mariano Rivera (9/6/19969/16/2009
7 Mike Timlin (9/14/19974/19/2007
6 Doug Brocail (8/2/19977/29/2005
6 Mark Eichhorn (7/14/19907/30/1994
6 Jonathan Papelbon (9/12/20058/21/2010
5 Mike Henneman (9/27/19874/17/1991
5 Hipolito Pichardo (7/8/19946/3/2001
5 Dave Righetti (6/8/19849/17/1987
5 Luis Sanchez (9/18/19824/20/1984
Most wins, 1970s |
1977 | 1978 | 1979 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 8 Mike Flanagan | |||
| 8 Dave Goltz | |||
| 7 Larry Gura | |||
| 7 Luis Tiant | |||
| 6 Dennis Eckersley | |||
| 6 Jim Slaton | |||
| 6 Rick Waits | |||
| 5 Don Aase | |||
| 5 Rick Honeycutt | |||
| 5 Ken Kravec | |||
| 5 Dennis Martinez | |||
| 5 Jim Palmer | |||
| 5 Lary Sorensen | |||
| 5 Paul Splittorff | |||
| 5 Mike Torrez | |||
| 5 Milt Wilcox |
Most wins, 1980s |
1980 | 1981 | 1982 | 1983 | 1984 | 1985 | 1986 | 1987 | 1988 | 1989 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 11 Scott McGregor | ||||||||||
| 11 Jack Morris | ||||||||||
| 10 Buddy Black | ||||||||||
| 10 Bob Stanley | ||||||||||
| 9 Floyd Bannister | ||||||||||
| 9 Richard Dotson | ||||||||||
| 9 Mike Flanagan | ||||||||||
| 8 Britt Burns | ||||||||||
| 8 Ron Guidry | ||||||||||
| 8 Dave Stewart |
Most wins, 1990s |
1990 | 1991 | 1992 | 1993 | 1994 | 1995 | 1996 | 1997 | 1998 | 1999 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12 Andy Pettitte | ||||||||||
| 11 Randy Johnson | ||||||||||
| 10 Mike Moore | ||||||||||
| 10 Bobby Witt | ||||||||||
| 9 Roger Clemens | ||||||||||
| 9 Tom Gordon | ||||||||||
| 9 Mike Mussina | ||||||||||
| 8 Kevin Appier | ||||||||||
| 8 Scott Erickson | ||||||||||
| 8 Charles Nagy | ||||||||||
| 8 Kenny Rogers |
Most wins, 2000s |
2000 | 2001 | 2002 | 2003 | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 16 Mike Mussina | |||||||||||
| 14 Tim Wakefield | |||||||||||
| 11 Jon Garland | |||||||||||
| 10 Jamie Moyer | |||||||||||
| 9 Roger Clemens | |||||||||||
| 9 Tim Hudson | |||||||||||
| 9 Andy Pettitte | |||||||||||
| 9 CC Sabathia |
Fewest days to win 8 games
616 Luis Tiant (9/23/1978-5/30/1980)
730 Mike Flanagan (9/14/1977[g1]-9/13/1979)
768 Roger Clemens (6/28/1990-8/3/1992)
779 Mike Mussina (7/22/2001-9/8/2003)
805 Dave Goltz (5/8/1977-7/21/1979[g1])
Fewest days to win 7 games
608 Luis Tiant (10/1/1978-5/30/1980)
610 Luis Tiant (9/23/1978-5/24/1980)
633 Mike Mussina (7/22/2001-4/15/2003)
660 Roger Clemens (6/28/1990-4/17/1992)
682 Roger Clemens (9/20/1989-8/2/1991)
Fewest days to win 6 games
345 Luis Tiant (6/21/1979-5/30/1980)
371 Luis Tiant (9/23/1978-9/28/1979)
401 Roger Clemens (6/28/1990-8/2/1991)
402 Clay Buchholz (7/17/2009-8/22/2010)
412 Dave Stewart (5/17/1987-7/1/1988)
Fewest days to win 5 games
300 Roger Clemens (6/28/1990-4/23/1991)
304 Mike Mussina (7/22/2001-5/21/2002)
326 Rick Waits (6/23/1978-5/14/1979)
335 Britt Burns (8/22/1981-7/22/1982)
336 David Price (7/9/2009-6/9/2010)
Fewest days to win 4 games
80 Britt Burns (5/4/1982, 5/10/1982, 7/11/1982, 7/22/1982
81 Dave Goltz (5/2/1979, 5/7/1979, 7/13/1979, 7/21/1979[g1]
81 Rick Waits (6/23/1978, 7/2/1978[g1], 9/5/1978, 9/11/1978[g1]
87 Steve Stone (6/26/1980, 6/30/1980, 9/11/1980, 9/20/1980
88 Rocky Coppinger (7/1/1996, 7/17/1996, 9/21/1996, 9/26/1996
Fewest days to win 3 games
21 Juan Rincon (4/27/2004, 4/28/2004, 5/17/2004
30 Shawn Chacon (8/25/2005, 9/17/2005, 9/23/2005
37 Mark Eichhorn (6/24/1994, 6/25/1994, 7/30/1994
38 Mike Mussina (7/22/2001, 7/27/2001, 8/28/2001
39 Rick Reed (7/15/2001, 8/2/2001, 8/22/2001
Fewest days to win 2 games
2 Mark Eichhorn (6/24/1994, 6/25/1994
2 Greg Harris (8/8/1986, 8/9/1986
2 Grant Jackson (4/30/1982, 5/1/1982
2 Tippy Martinez (8/24/1983, 8/25/1983
2 T.J. Mathews (9/10/1997, 9/11/1997
2 Jose Mesa (6/14/1994, 6/15/1994
2 Jonathan Papelbon (4/29/2008, 4/30/2008
2 Juan Rincon (4/27/2004, 4/28/2004
2 Elias Sosa (7/15/1978, 7/16/1978
Longest drought between wins
4752 Mike Morgan (5/3/19865/8/1999
4604 Rich Gossage (9/20/1978[g2]4/30/1991
4127 Julian Tavarez (6/4/19959/22/2006
3996 Doug Drabek (9/11/1986[g1]8/21/1997
3602 Mark Guthrie (9/14/19897/27/1999
3579 Rick Sutcliffe (8/17/1982[g2]6/5/1992
3535 Nolan Ryan (8/18/19794/23/1989
3423 Al Leiter (4/14/19888/29/1997
3402 Kevin Brown (5/5/19958/28/2004
3317 Dennis Martinez (4/21/19855/22/1994
Includes all games played between 1977 and 2010.
The information used here was obtained free of charge from and is copyrighted by Retrosheet. Interested parties may contact Retrosheet at “www.retrosheet.org“.