Batter vs Pitcher (born in 1933)

Batter vs Pitcher (born in 1933)

Who are the top head-to-head performers?

Back to Excruciating Baseball Lists
Overall Records
Players born in
1923192419251926192719281929
1930193119321933193419351936193719381939
1940194119421943194419451946194719481949
1950195119521953195419551956195719581959
1960196119621963196419651966196719681969
1970197119721973197419751976197719781979
19801981
Players whose last name starts with

Players born in 1933

Ted Abernathy (1955-1972)
Racked Skunked High OPS Low OPS
H: 10 (29) J. Callison
XBH: 6 (19) T. Williams
1B: 8 (29) J. Callison
2B: 4 (23) W. Parker
3B: 3 (13) H. Simpson
HR: 3 (29) W. Mays
RBI: 8 (19) T. Williams
BB: 9 (28) W. McCovey
SO: 9 (27) J. Javier
HBP: 2 (5) M. Epstein
H: 0 (14) K. Boyer
XBH: 0 (28) B. Mazeroski
1B: 0 (22) C. Rojas
2B: 0 (29) W. Mays
3B: 0 (31) T. McCarver
HR: 0 (34) A. Kaline
RBI: 0 (27) T. Haller
BB: 0 (30) F. Alou
SO: 0 (31) T. McCarver
HBP: 0 (34) A. Kaline
0.645 (34) A. Kaline 0.610 (30) F. Alou
0.540 (31) T. McCarver
Bob Bruce (1959-1967)
Racked Skunked High OPS Low OPS
H: 19 (46) T. Gonzalez
XBH: 8 (46) T. Gonzalez
1B: 16 (65) M. Wills
2B: 5 (30) W. Parker
3B: 2 (24) B. Skinner
HR: 3 (44) J. Edwards
HR: 3 (44) E. Mathews
HR: 3 (44) R. Santo
RBI: 12 (54) J. Roseboro
BB: 10 (42) W. McCovey
SO: 11 (38) T. Haller
HBP: 3 (33) O. Cepeda
H: 0 (14) D. Ellsworth
XBH: 0 (44) H. Aaron
1B: 0 (14) D. Ellsworth
1B: 0 (14) P. Runnels
2B: 0 (44) H. Aaron
3B: 0 (61) R. Fairly
HR: 0 (65) M. Wills
RBI: 0 (26) J. Pagan
BB: 0 (36) J. Javier
SO: 0 (20) B. Wine
HBP: 0 (61) R. Fairly
1.207 (46) T. Gonzalez
1.164 (30) F. Alou
1.098 (30) W. Parker
1.082 (44) J. Edwards
1.020 (44) E. Mathews
1.000 (54) J. Roseboro
0.989 (40) B. Virdon
0.981 (37) F. Robinson
0.974 (38) W. Covington
0.973 (44) R. Santo
0.633 (42) C. Dalrymple
0.598 (58) W. Davis
0.595 (33) D. Clendenon
0.594 (37) D. Schofield
0.509 (36) G. Coleman
0.506 (44) D. Groat
0.425 (44) H. Aaron
0.413 (32) T. McCarver
0.372 (43) B. Bailey
0.242 (40) C. Hiller
Ed Charles (1962-1969)
Racked Skunked High OPS Low OPS
H: 18 (75) C. Osteen
XBH: 9 (75) C. Osteen
1B: 12 (61) E. Wilson
2B: 6 (75) C. Osteen
3B: 2 (19) M. Lopez
HR: 3 (22) K. Holtzman
RBI: 9 (28) J. Horlen
BB: 10 (75) C. Osteen
SO: 11 (58) W. Ford
HBP: 2 (37) J. Buzhardt
H: 0 (12) E. Wynn
XBH: 0 (43) A. Downing
1B: 0 (13) D. Hughes
2B: 0 (43) A. Downing
3B: 0 (61) G. Peters
HR: 0 (58) M. McCormick
RBI: 0 (25) E. Fisher
RBI: 0 (25) D. Mossi
BB: 0 (35) P. Ramos
SO: 0 (22) D. McNally
HBP: 0 (75) C. Osteen
1.325 (30) B. Veale
1.066 (35) M. Lolich
1.005 (36) P. Regan
0.910 (61) E. Wilson
0.870 (45) D. Chance
0.866 (75) C. Osteen
0.862 (58) W. Ford
0.853 (40) R. Terry
0.850 (55) S. Barber
0.766 (42) J. Kaat
0.641 (62) C. Pascual
0.635 (40) J. Bouton
0.634 (40) J. Perry
0.601 (58) M. McCormick
0.580 (42) R. Roberts
0.556 (35) P. Ramos
0.555 (43) S. McDowell
0.467 (32) B. Latman
0.408 (43) A. Downing
0.406 (31) B. Daniels
Rocky Colavito (1955-1968)
Racked Skunked High OPS Low OPS
H: 30 (113) P. Ramos
XBH: 14 (87) R. Terry
1B: 22 (97) D. Donovan
2B: 6 (54) B. Daniels
3B: 1 (1) S. Lyle
HR: 12 (87) R. Terry
RBI: 26 (87) R. Terry
BB: 18 (124) C. Pascual
SO: 20 (98) B. Pierce
HBP: 2 (30) M. Fornieles
H: 0 (13) J. Santiago
XBH: 0 (34) H. Aguirre
1B: 0 (23) F. Talbot
2B: 0 (82) D. Chance
3B: 0 (124) C. Pascual
HR: 0 (52) H. Brown
RBI: 0 (34) H. Aguirre
BB: 0 (34) F. Newman
SO: 0 (35) W. Bunker
HBP: 0 (113) P. Ramos
1.436 (31) H. Griggs
1.381 (32) P. Richert
1.286 (53) D. Stigman
1.282 (45) T. Clevenger
1.273 (67) B. Latman
1.265 (31) D. Morehead
1.243 (54) B. Daniels
1.241 (50) B. Daley
1.215 (56) G. Bell
1.188 (42) D. Sisler
0.588 (34) F. Newman
0.583 (35) W. Bunker
0.566 (41) M. Lolich
0.553 (51) B. Stafford
0.509 (34) R. Roberts
0.495 (35) D. Radatz
0.494 (42) D. Maas
0.343 (30) P. Ortega
0.303 (37) D. McLain
0.180 (34) H. Aguirre
Jim Davenport (1958-1970)
Racked Skunked High OPS Low OPS
H: 27 (127) D. Drysdale
XBH: 8 (76) J. O’Toole
1B: 21 (127) D. Drysdale
2B: 5 (57) B. Gibson
3B: 2 (24) D. Giusti
HR: 4 (46) R. Craig
RBI: 12 (46) R. Craig
BB: 9 (73) S. Koufax
SO: 30 (127) D. Drysdale
HBP: 3 (8) B. Muffett
H: 0 (17) C. Raydon
XBH: 0 (40) J. Bunning
1B: 0 (17) C. Raydon
2B: 0 (56) K. Johnson
3B: 0 (127) D. Drysdale
HR: 0 (86) L. Jackson
RBI: 0 (28) D. Green
BB: 0 (40) J. Bunning
SO: 0 (21) R. Semproch
HBP: 0 (102) W. Spahn
1.086 (32) R. Culp
1.050 (46) R. Craig
1.029 (35) B. Miller
0.997 (55) V. Mizell
0.967 (76) J. O’Toole
0.919 (54) R. Sadecki
0.915 (35) A. Jackson
0.899 (47) C. Short
0.896 (49) G. Hobbie
0.880 (73) S. Koufax
0.512 (72) B. Purkey
0.484 (49) T. Farrell
0.470 (41) A. Mahaffey
0.466 (37) N. Briles
0.419 (39) D. Drott
0.418 (33) T. Cloninger
0.411 (39) D. Elston
0.361 (35) R. Face
0.342 (39) R. Roberts
0.156 (40) J. Bunning
Tito Francona (1956-1970)
Racked Skunked High OPS Low OPS
H: 32 (115) J. Bunning
XBH: 11 (115) J. Bunning
1B: 21 (115) J. Bunning
2B: 7 (26) D. Wickersham
3B: 1 (4) P. Charton
3B: 1 (4) J. Gibbon
3B: 1 (4) E. Kinder
3B: 1 (4) B. Sadowski
HR: 5 (115) J. Bunning
RBI: 17 (115) J. Bunning
BB: 12 (48) D. Larsen
SO: 21 (81) C. Pascual
HBP: 3 (92) F. Lary
H: 0 (18) D. Morehead
XBH: 0 (33) B. Hoeft
1B: 0 (18) D. Morehead
2B: 0 (42) J. Marichal
3B: 0 (115) J. Bunning
HR: 0 (62) P. Ramos
RBI: 0 (40) B. Pierce
BB: 0 (40) D. Donovan
SO: 0 (36) K. McBride
HBP: 0 (102) M. Pappas
1.328 (36) J. Coates
1.238 (38) N. Garver
1.129 (42) B. Turley
1.042 (55) B. Shaw
1.035 (36) D. Segui
1.032 (69) P. Foytack
0.939 (30) D. Cardwell
0.895 (31) H. Wilhelm
0.885 (52) B. Fischer
0.866 (35) D. Sisler
0.567 (35) T. Sturdivant
0.528 (49) T. Brewer
0.522 (53) H. Brown
0.501 (53) A. Ditmar
0.493 (33) J. Kaat
0.492 (32) J. Pizarro
0.486 (67) J. Fisher
0.472 (31) B. Singer
0.455 (67) W. Ford
0.416 (33) B. Hoeft
Ken Johnson (1958-1970)
Racked Skunked High OPS Low OPS
H: 25 (81) T. Haller
XBH: 11 (76) E. Banks
1B: 21 (81) T. Haller
2B: 6 (76) E. Banks
3B: 2 (8) J. Becquer
HR: 5 (69) J. Hart
RBI: 16 (76) E. Banks
BB: 17 (91) W. McCovey
SO: 19 (91) R. Santo
HBP: 5 (66) T. Taylor
H: 0 (11) E. Battey
XBH: 0 (37) E. Mathews
1B: 0 (17) B. Gibson
2B: 0 (91) R. Santo
3B: 0 (91) W. McCovey
3B: 0 (91) R. Santo
HR: 0 (63) M. Wills
RBI: 0 (49) G. Beckert
BB: 0 (75) C. Flood
SO: 0 (38) C. Hiller
HBP: 0 (91) J. Callison
HBP: 0 (91) B. Williams
1.187 (35) H. Aaron
1.089 (34) W. Stargell
1.080 (43) B. Skinner
1.067 (35) E. Kranepool
1.055 (55) D. Allen
0.977 (32) A. Phillips
0.969 (43) F. Robinson
0.952 (91) W. McCovey
0.945 (43) T. Harper
0.934 (52) J. Edwards
0.514 (75) C. Flood
0.506 (54) J. Javier
0.482 (37) E. Mathews
0.481 (54) R. Clemente
0.475 (30) D. Maxvill
0.459 (49) H. Lanier
0.441 (30) R. Hundley
0.372 (30) R. Sievers
0.371 (49) G. Beckert
0.340 (32) J. Briggs
Johnny Kucks (1955-1960)
Racked Skunked High OPS Low OPS
H: 22 (50) G. Woodling
XBH: 8 (70) A. Smith
1B: 19 (50) G. Woodling
2B: 4 (63) H. Lopez
3B: 2 (21) E. Battey
HR: 4 (57) E. Yost
RBI: 13 (50) G. Woodling
BB: 10 (55) C. Maxwell
SO: 9 (70) A. Smith
HBP: 4 (57) E. Yost
H: 0 (15) F. Lary
XBH: 0 (35) J. DeMaestri
1B: 0 (15) F. Lary
2B: 0 (57) E. Yost
3B: 0 (70) A. Smith
HR: 0 (64) V. Power
RBI: 0 (36) B. Goodman
BB: 0 (34) F. Malzone
SO: 0 (50) G. Woodling
HBP: 0 (70) A. Smith
1.229 (50) G. Woodling
1.180 (34) H. Simpson
1.109 (49) J. Lemon
1.025 (60) A. Kaline
1.008 (37) R. Nixon
0.967 (41) F. Bolling
0.952 (36) B. Goodman
0.941 (55) C. Maxwell
0.924 (51) R. Sievers
0.892 (36) R. Maris
0.603 (53) B. Avila
0.603 (34) A. Rosen
0.600 (31) G. Stephens
0.586 (42) S. Lollar
0.562 (42) C. Courtney
0.531 (30) J. Landis
0.494 (39) E. Torgeson
0.412 (34) F. Malzone
0.394 (35) J. DeMaestri
0.343 (39) A. Pilarcik
Jerry Lumpe (1956-1967)
Racked Skunked High OPS Low OPS
H: 28 (102) M. Pappas
XBH: 7 (64) G. Bell
1B: 24 (102) M. Pappas
2B: 5 (64) G. Bell
3B: 2 (11) J. Spring
HR: 4 (85) R. Terry
RBI: 11 (116) C. Pascual
BB: 10 (84) B. Monbouquette
SO: 16 (116) C. Pascual
HBP: 1 (7) S. Ridzik
H: 0 (15) G. Staley
H: 0 (15) F. Talbot
XBH: 0 (51) R. Herbert
1B: 0 (23) R. Narleski
2B: 0 (85) R. Terry
3B: 0 (116) C. Pascual
HR: 0 (102) M. Pappas
RBI: 0 (42) J. Bouton
BB: 0 (53) D. Mossi
SO: 0 (57) B. Latman
HBP: 0 (102) M. Pappas
1.068 (36) R. Sheldon
1.066 (35) D. Lee
0.998 (64) J. Bunning
0.935 (30) D. Segui
0.906 (33) T. Clevenger
0.888 (64) G. Bell
0.880 (33) H. Brown
0.856 (46) D. Donovan
0.806 (57) B. Latman
0.800 (33) W. Bunker
0.485 (39) C. Estrada
0.481 (52) J. Kaat
0.475 (30) F. Newman
0.472 (49) R. Roberts
0.471 (44) B. Daniels
0.461 (33) F. Sullivan
0.416 (51) R. Herbert
0.353 (38) A. Downing
0.346 (39) L. Stange
0.153 (42) J. Bouton
Billy O’Dell (1954-1967)
Racked Skunked High OPS Low OPS
H: 27 (82) D. Groat
XBH: 8 (64) V. Pinson
1B: 22 (82) D. Groat
2B: 6 (64) V. Pinson
3B: 3 (35) B. Tuttle
HR: 4 (39) F. Howard
RBI: 14 (78) R. Santo
BB: 11 (76) E. Banks
SO: 20 (74) T. Taylor
HBP: 4 (86) N. Fox
H: 0 (15) B. Buhl
XBH: 0 (67) R. Sievers
1B: 0 (17) D. Buddin
2B: 0 (67) R. Sievers
3B: 0 (83) B. White
HR: 0 (86) N. Fox
RBI: 0 (45) B. Aspromonte
BB: 0 (41) B. Virdon
SO: 0 (29) C. Carrasquel
HBP: 0 (83) B. White
1.150 (40) H. Aaron
1.144 (41) F. Robinson
1.045 (33) D. Allen
1.043 (39) F. Howard
1.007 (42) F. Thomas
1.005 (30) P. Rose
0.989 (57) T. Davis
0.967 (35) B. Tuttle
0.938 (30) J. Jensen
0.900 (45) C. James
0.448 (47) T. Gonzalez
0.424 (37) D. Stuart
0.406 (40) J. Lemon
0.391 (32) B. Skinner
0.390 (45) B. Aspromonte
0.390 (41) B. Virdon
0.382 (41) M. Minoso
0.350 (45) R. Fairly
0.329 (40) C. Rojas
0.310 (31) C. Dalrymple
Orlando Pena (1958-1975)
Racked Skunked High OPS Low OPS
H: 18 (51) J. Fregosi
XBH: 8 (51) J. Fregosi
1B: 11 (28) E. Howard
2B: 6 (51) J. Fregosi
3B: 2 (14) J. Foy
3B: 2 (14) R. Repoz
HR: 4 (32) D. Lock
RBI: 9 (36) D. McAuliffe
BB: 11 (40) C. Yastrzemski
SO: 12 (26) J. Brandt
HBP: 2 (15) B. Johnson
H: 0 (12) D. McNally
XBH: 0 (33) V. Davalillo
1B: 0 (21) J. Hall
2B: 0 (33) V. Davalillo
3B: 0 (44) B. Robinson
HR: 0 (40) B. Bruton
RBI: 0 (32) E. Bressoud
RBI: 0 (32) B. Moran
BB: 0 (32) J. Adair
SO: 0 (39) A. Pearson
HBP: 0 (44) B. Robinson
1.359 (40) C. Yastrzemski
1.165 (36) D. McAuliffe
1.153 (32) D. Lock
1.097 (41) Z. Versalles
1.081 (51) J. Fregosi
1.046 (39) B. Powell
1.026 (38) H. Killebrew
1.021 (39) T. Tresh
1.014 (44) B. Robinson
0.992 (41) L. Thomas
0.722 (39) A. Pearson
0.688 (32) J. Adair
0.685 (41) B. Rodgers
0.659 (42) L. Wagner
0.643 (31) B. Allison
0.556 (38) W. Kirkland
0.522 (31) L. Green
0.499 (32) E. Bressoud
0.365 (30) M. Hershberger
0.343 (30) D. Stuart
John Roseboro (1957-1970)
Racked Skunked High OPS Low OPS
H: 33 (142) L. Jackson
XBH: 9 (142) L. Jackson
1B: 24 (142) L. Jackson
2B: 7 (142) L. Jackson
3B: 3 (38) R. Kline
HR: 3 (40) C. Willey
RBI: 12 (54) B. Bruce
BB: 18 (91) B. Gibson
SO: 18 (100) J. Jay
HBP: 3 (47) J. Bunning
H: 0 (18) J. Nuxhall
XBH: 0 (39) D. Ellsworth
1B: 0 (18) J. Nuxhall
2B: 0 (100) J. Jay
3B: 0 (142) L. Jackson
HR: 0 (71) T. Farrell
RBI: 0 (67) E. Broglio
BB: 0 (36) R. Craig
SO: 0 (30) C. Koonce
HBP: 0 (99) J. Marichal
1.025 (38) R. Kline
1.017 (32) T. Stallard
1.000 (54) B. Bruce
0.964 (31) T. Cloninger
0.908 (48) B. Anderson
0.899 (33) S. Miller
0.895 (40) C. Willey
0.864 (34) D. Nottebart
0.861 (91) B. Gibson
0.861 (41) R. Face
0.554 (64) R. Roberts
0.551 (39) D. Ellsworth
0.509 (34) M. Drabowsky
0.483 (67) E. Broglio
0.475 (40) C. Short
0.473 (37) D. McLain
0.451 (42) B. Shaw
0.407 (35) C. Simmons
0.389 (36) R. Craig
0.378 (99) J. Marichal
Herb Score (1955-1962)
Racked Skunked High OPS Low OPS
H: 24 (63) H. Lopez
XBH: 9 (63) H. Lopez
1B: 15 (63) H. Lopez
2B: 4 (48) V. Power
3B: 2 (48) E. Howard
HR: 5 (63) H. Lopez
RBI: 17 (63) H. Lopez
BB: 17 (58) E. Yost
SO: 13 (44) J. Lemon
HBP: 1 (4) R. Jackson
H: 0 (15) K. Olson
XBH: 0 (43) R. Wilson
1B: 0 (29) B. Klaus
2B: 0 (58) E. Yost
3B: 0 (79) B. Tuttle
HR: 0 (62) H. Kuenn
RBI: 0 (39) R. Bertoia
BB: 0 (21) C. Boyer
SO: 0 (24) B. Robinson
HBP: 0 (79) B. Tuttle
1.231 (63) H. Lopez
1.201 (34) T. Williams
1.005 (32) J. Piersall
0.956 (47) G. Zernial
0.904 (43) J. Jensen
0.894 (67) A. Kaline
0.869 (44) J. Lemon
0.859 (53) M. Mantle
0.858 (48) P. Runnels
0.826 (46) W. Dropo
0.508 (39) J. Busby
0.499 (52) N. Fox
0.488 (46) S. Lollar
0.482 (38) F. Bolling
0.479 (35) M. Minoso
0.467 (39) L. Aparicio
0.433 (41) J. DeMaestri
0.393 (43) R. Wilson
0.378 (39) R. Bertoia
0.326 (38) J. Finigan
Bob Shaw (1957-1967)
Racked Skunked High OPS Low OPS
H: 22 (52) R. Clemente
XBH: 7 (54) R. Maris
1B: 18 (52) R. Clemente
2B: 5 (54) R. Maris
3B: 2 (52) V. Pinson
HR: 4 (33) J. Gentile
RBI: 14 (55) T. Francona
BB: 12 (47) M. Mantle
SO: 14 (46) J. Javier
HBP: 4 (40) O. Cepeda
H: 0 (19) S. Boros
XBH: 0 (38) H. Smith
1B: 0 (23) J. Briggs
2B: 0 (51) B. White
3B: 0 (65) L. Brock
HR: 0 (65) L. Brock
RBI: 0 (45) R. Fairly
BB: 0 (52) D. Groat
SO: 0 (41) A. Kaline
HBP: 0 (65) L. Brock
1.207 (41) A. Kaline
1.194 (33) J. Gentile
1.076 (32) T. Gonzalez
1.072 (52) R. Clemente
1.070 (40) J. Edwards
1.063 (52) V. Pinson
1.049 (52) J. Lemon
1.045 (35) M. Keough
1.042 (55) T. Francona
1.040 (40) G. Woodling
0.562 (58) M. Wills
0.537 (40) M. Throneberry
0.532 (31) G. Alley
0.530 (31) C. Maxwell
0.518 (46) J. Javier
0.493 (35) J. Lumpe
0.469 (38) H. Smith
0.451 (42) J. Roseboro
0.442 (45) R. Fairly
0.439 (42) T. Kubek
Norm Siebern (1956-1968)
Racked Skunked High OPS Low OPS
H: 25 (78) R. Terry
XBH: 15 (78) R. Terry
1B: 18 (94) F. Lary
2B: 7 (63) B. Monbouquette
3B: 4 (78) R. Terry
HR: 5 (34) H. Brown
RBI: 15 (78) R. Terry
BB: 14 (87) M. Grant
SO: 32 (125) C. Pascual
HBP: 1 (3) K. Lehman
H: 0 (13) J. Bonikowski
H: 0 (13) J. O’Donoghue
XBH: 0 (37) P. Burnside
1B: 0 (16) T. Sturdivant
2B: 0 (68) E. Wynn
3B: 0 (94) F. Lary
HR: 0 (66) S. Barber
RBI: 0 (29) D. Radatz
BB: 0 (23) C. Stobbs
SO: 0 (28) J. Lamabe
HBP: 0 (125) C. Pascual
1.192 (34) H. Brown
1.166 (39) R. Kemmerer
1.117 (63) B. Monbouquette
1.112 (78) R. Terry
1.100 (45) T. Brewer
1.036 (32) R. Sheldon
1.034 (53) B. Daniels
1.032 (44) D. Chance
0.993 (30) J. Harshman
0.981 (61) E. Wilson
0.555 (30) A. Downing
0.546 (65) H. Wilhelm
0.533 (53) B. Latman
0.530 (63) W. Ford
0.506 (66) S. Barber
0.476 (36) C. Osteen
0.459 (65) D. Donovan
0.405 (63) M. Pappas
0.372 (31) G. Peters
0.337 (37) P. Burnside

Plate appearances shown in parentheses.
Racked: Against which opponent did this player rack up the highest total in the indicated category? Ties are broken in order of fewest plate appearances.
Skunked: Which opponent did this player face the most times without ever registering in the indicated category?
High or Low OPS: Against which 10 opponents did this player compile the highest (or lowest) sum of on-base percentage and slugging average, with a minimum of 30 plate appearances?
Players are included if they totaled at least 3500 plate appearances or batters faced during the seasons listed below.
Includes all games played between 1974 and 2010, and almost all games played between 1950 and 1973. Can you help? The figures shown may not reflect the entire career of either the batter or the pitcher. In all probability, the rankings will change as additional games and seasons are released by Retrosheet. This page is presented for entertainment purposes only. Excruciating Baseball Lists accepts no responsibility for any disputes which may arise in response to any trivia questions posed based on information listed hereon.
The information used here was obtained free of charge from and is copyrighted by Retrosheet. Interested parties may contact Retrosheet at “www.retrosheet.org“.