Who are the top head-to-head performers?

Back to Excruciating Baseball Lists
Overall Records
Players whose last name starts with
  A B C D E F G H J K L M N O P R S T U V W Y Z

Pat Zachry (1976-1985)
RackedSkunkedHigh OPSLow OPS
H: 21 (72) B. Buckner
XBH: 8 (72) B. Buckner
1B: 15 (61) G. Carter
2B: 6 (54) C. Speier
3B: 1 (2) J. Samuel
HR: 5 (42) D. Baker
RBI: 13 (47) J. Cruz
BB: 15 (53) K. Hernandez
SO: 11 (42) M. Schmidt
HBP: 2 (46) R. Cey
HBP: 2 (46) I. DeJesus
HBP: 2 (46) B. Russell
H: 0 (10) E. Milner
XBH: 0 (46) I. DeJesus
1B: 0 (29) B. Murcer
2B: 0 (46) R. Cey
2B: 0 (46) I. DeJesus
3B: 0 (72) B. Buckner
HR: 0 (61) G. Carter
RBI: 0 (32) D. Cash
BB: 0 (32) D. Cash
SO: 0 (46) P. Rose
HBP: 0 (72) B. Buckner
1.314 (53) K. Hernandez
1.308 (46) R. Cey
1.278 (31) D. Evans
1.126 (42) D. Baker
1.059 (31) R. Smith
1.024 (34) D. Driessen
0.960 (50) L. Bowa
0.931 (55) S. Garvey
0.904 (47) J. Cruz
0.895 (35) E. Cabell
0.596 (55) A. Dawson
0.589 (41) J. Royster
0.587 (31) G. Foster
0.578 (46) I. DeJesus
0.567 (30) L. Biittner
0.565 (36) D. Lopes
0.517 (46) B. Russell
0.460 (31) B. McBride
0.390 (35) T. Simmons
0.279 (41) D. Concepcion

Geoff Zahn (1973-1985)
RackedSkunkedHigh OPSLow OPS
H: 28 (76) H. McRae
XBH: 10 (45) E. Murray
1B: 21 (62) R. Henderson
2B: 7 (97) W. Randolph
3B: 2 (20) D. Ault
HR: 6 (51) D. Baylor
RBI: 16 (45) E. Murray
BB: 8 (27) G. Luzinski
SO: 9 (31) M. Page
HBP: 1 (5) B. North
H: 0 (13) D. Evans
XBH: 0 (54) D. Murphy
XBH: 0 (54) J. Wathan
1B: 0 (20) C. Cooper
2B: 0 (62) R. Henderson
3B: 0 (76) H. McRae
HR: 0 (97) W. Randolph
RBI: 0 (45) J. Sundberg
BB: 0 (62) F. White
SO: 0 (47) M. Rivers
HBP: 0 (97) W. Randolph
1.259 (34) K. Hrbek
1.146 (45) E. Murray
1.133 (76) H. McRae
1.082 (51) D. Baylor
1.057 (36) R. Jackson
1.027 (32) C. Fisk
1.011 (62) R. Henderson
0.990 (41) R. Jones
0.987 (31) B. Ayala
0.979 (70) R. Zisk
0.526 (41) J. Newman
0.519 (62) G. Nettles
0.518 (44) C. Lansford
0.500 (42) A. Trammell
0.491 (34) R. Smalley
0.484 (54) J. Wathan
0.475 (30) D. Lopes
0.467 (46) R. Cerone
0.426 (35) B. Wills
0.414 (45) J. Sundberg

Richie Zisk (1971-1983)
RackedSkunkedHigh OPSLow OPS
H: 26 (93) J. Koosman
XBH: 10 (93) J. Koosman
1B: 16 (93) J. Koosman
2B: 8 (93) J. Koosman
3B: 3 (47) B. Bonham
HR: 5 (70) G. Zahn
RBI: 14 (70) G. Zahn
BB: 8 (51) L. Gura
SO: 16 (42) T. Seaver
HBP: 1 (4) D. Cooper
H: 0 (16) J. Coleman
XBH: 0 (47) R. Waits
1B: 0 (22) S. Rawley
2B: 0 (51) L. Gura
3B: 0 (93) J. Koosman
HR: 0 (47) B. Bonham
HR: 0 (47) R. Waits
RBI: 0 (40) S. Rogers
BB: 0 (49) S. Renko
SO: 0 (24) V. Blue
HBP: 0 (93) J. Koosman
1.283 (30) D. Martinez
1.270 (35) J. Barr
1.208 (37) R. Langford
1.118 (39) P. Niekro
1.095 (51) L. Gura
1.015 (30) D. Gullett
0.991 (47) B. Bonham
0.979 (70) G. Zahn
0.945 (58) M. Caldwell
0.930 (39) R. Jones
0.592 (32) J. Curtis
0.576 (31) J. Denny
0.569 (30) M. Marshall
0.548 (34) M. Flanagan
0.522 (35) D. Sutton
0.518 (40) S. Rogers
0.510 (49) S. Renko
0.488 (61) D. Leonard
0.486 (47) R. Waits
0.481 (32) W. Fryman

Plate appearances shown in parentheses.
Racked: Against which opponent did this player rack up the highest total in the indicated category? Ties are broken in order of fewest plate appearances.
Skunked: Which opponent did this player face the most times without ever registering in the indicated category?
High or Low OPS: Against which 10 opponents did this player compile the highest (or lowest) sum of on-base percentage and slugging average, with a minimum of 30 plate appearances?
Players are included if they totaled at least 5000 plate appearances or batters faced (2000 for Hall of Fame members) during the seasons listed below.
Includes all games played between 2000 and 2004, all games played between 1974 and 1992, almost all games played between 1960 and 1973, and almost all A.L. games from 1959. Can you help? The figures shown may not reflect the entire career of either the batter or the pitcher. In all probability, the rankings will change as additional games and seasons are released by Retrosheet. This page is presented for entertainment purposes only. Excruciating Baseball Lists accepts no responsibility for any disputes which may arise in response to any trivia questions posed based on information listed hereon.
The information used here was obtained free of charge from and is copyrighted by Retrosheet. Interested parties may contact Retrosheet at 20 Sunset Rd., Newark, DE 19711.