Who won the most games against the Toronto Blue Jays?

Back to Excruciating Baseball Lists

Overall records
ANAARIATLBALBOSCHACHNCINCLECOLDETFLOHOUKCALAN
MILMINNYANYNOAKPHIPITSDNSEASFNSLNTBATEXTORWAS

Most wins, career

24 Roger Clemens (6/22/1984-8/7/2007)
23 Mike Mussina (6/7/1992-9/23/2007)
17 Mike Flanagan (9/14/1977[g1]-8/11/1986)
16 Andy Pettitte (9/19/1995-8/6/2007)
15 Tim Wakefield (8/5/1996-7/12/2007)
14 Randy Johnson (7/23/1989-4/29/2006)
14 Mike Moore (6/21/1982-8/6/1994)
14 Jack Morris (5/28/1979-9/28/1991)
14 Kenny Rogers (4/9/1989-7/9/2005)
14 Bob Stanley (7/7/1977-4/12/1987)
13 Tom Gordon (4/5/1989-7/24/2003)
13 Dennis Martinez (6/17/1977-7/24/1996)
13 Scott McGregor (9/9/1978-8/2/1986)
13 Jamie Moyer (4/8/1989-7/26/2006)
12 Dennis Eckersley (7/8/1977-7/8/1995[g2])
12 Bobby Witt (4/22/1986-6/27/1999)
11 Buddy Black (7/19/1983-5/2/1990)
11 Ron Guidry (9/25/1977[g1]-6/30/1987)
11 Larry Gura (5/1/1977-7/13/1983)
11 Moose Haas (5/2/1977-5/27/1987)
11 Brad Radke (5/16/1996-8/13/2006)
11 Jim Slaton (5/19/1977-5/1/1986)

Most wins, relief

10 Bob Stanley (9/29/1977-6/30/1986)
7 Tippy Martinez (9/3/1979[g1]-4/13/1985)
7 Mike Timlin (9/14/1997-4/19/2007)
6 Doug Brocail (8/2/1997-7/29/2005)
6 Mark Eichhorn (7/14/1990-7/30/1994)
6 Mariano Rivera (9/6/1996-8/23/2005)
5 Mike Henneman (9/27/1987-4/17/1991)
5 Hipolito Pichardo (7/8/1994-6/3/2001)
5 Dave Righetti (6/8/1984-9/17/1987)
5 Luis Sanchez (9/18/1982-4/20/1984)

Most wins, 1970s

197719781979
8 Mike Flanagan233
8 Dave Goltz314
7 Larry Gura223
7 Luis Tiant124
6 Dennis Eckersley24 
6 Jim Slaton213
6 Rick Waits141
5 Don Aase212
5 Rick Honeycutt 32
5 Ken Kravec212
5 Dennis Martinez212
5 Jim Palmer311
5 Lary Sorensen122
5 Paul Splittorff311
5 Mike Torrez122
5 Milt Wilcox122

Most wins, 1980s

1980198119821983198419851986198719881989
11 Scott McGregor2212211   
11 Jack Morris2131112   
10 Buddy Black   1 21312
10 Bob Stanley11 21221  
9 Floyd Bannister111211 11 
9 Richard Dotson11 21 211 
9 Mike Flanagan223   2   
8 Britt Burns114  2    
8 Ron Guidry2  21111  
8 Dave Stewart      1421

Most wins, 1990s

1990199119921993199419951996199719981999
12 Andy Pettitte     23133
11 Randy Johnson1 1311121 
10 Mike Moore24121     
10 Bobby Witt1  2 231 1
9 Roger Clemens332  1    
9 Tom Gordon21  122 1 
9 Mike Mussina  1 23  21
8 Kevin Appier  21 21  2
8 Scott Erickson 11 11211 
8 Charles Nagy  21111 11
8 Kenny Rogers 2 211  11

Most wins, 2000s

20002001200220032004200520062007
14 Mike Mussina 323 132
12 Tim Wakefield 12141 3
9 Roger Clemens2411   1
9 Jon Garland 1211121
9 Tim Hudson31122   
7 Jamie Moyer121 111 
7 Sidney Ponson12 211  
6 Joe Kennedy 312    
6 Esteban Loaiza   12111
6 C.C. Sabathia 11 1111
6 Mike Timlin   311 1
6 Steve Trachsel11    13

Fewest days to win 8 games

616 Luis Tiant (9/23/1978-5/30/1980)
730 Mike Flanagan (9/14/1977[g1]-9/13/1979)
768 Roger Clemens (6/28/1990-8/3/1992)
779 Mike Mussina (7/22/2001-9/8/2003)
805 Dave Goltz (5/8/1977-7/21/1979[g1])

Fewest days to win 7 games

608 Luis Tiant (10/1/1978-5/30/1980)
610 Luis Tiant (9/23/1978-5/24/1980)
633 Mike Mussina (7/22/2001-4/15/2003)
660 Roger Clemens (6/28/1990-4/17/1992)
682 Roger Clemens (9/20/1989-8/2/1991)

Fewest days to win 6 games

345 Luis Tiant (6/21/1979-5/30/1980)
371 Luis Tiant (9/23/1978-9/28/1979)
401 Roger Clemens (6/28/1990-8/2/1991)
412 Dave Stewart (5/17/1987-7/1/1988)
447 Mike Moore (7/2/1990-9/21/1991)

Fewest days to win 5 games

300 Roger Clemens (6/28/1990-4/23/1991)
304 Mike Mussina (7/22/2001-5/21/2002)
326 Rick Waits (6/23/1978-5/14/1979)
335 Britt Burns (8/22/1981-7/22/1982)
339 Luis Tiant (6/21/1979-5/24/1980)

Fewest days to win 4 games

80 Britt Burns (5/4/1982, 5/10/1982, 7/11/1982, 7/22/1982)
81 Dave Goltz (5/2/1979, 5/7/1979, 7/13/1979, 7/21/1979[g1])
81 Rick Waits (6/23/1978, 7/2/1978[g1], 9/5/1978, 9/11/1978[g1])
87 Steve Stone (6/26/1980, 6/30/1980, 9/11/1980, 9/20/1980)
88 Rocky Coppinger (7/1/1996, 7/17/1996, 9/21/1996, 9/26/1996)

Fewest days to win 3 games

21 Juan Rincon (4/27/2004, 4/28/2004, 5/17/2004)
30 Shawn Chacon (8/25/2005, 9/17/2005, 9/23/2005)
37 Mark Eichhorn (6/24/1994, 6/25/1994, 7/30/1994)
38 Mike Mussina (7/22/2001, 7/27/2001, 8/28/2001)
39 Rick Reed (7/15/2001, 8/2/2001, 8/22/2001)

Fewest days to win 2 games

2 Mark Eichhorn (6/24/1994, 6/25/1994)
2 Greg Harris (8/8/1986, 8/9/1986)
2 Grant Jackson (4/30/1982, 5/1/1982)
2 Tippy Martinez (8/24/1983, 8/25/1983)
2 T.J. Mathews (9/10/1997, 9/11/1997)
2 Jose Mesa (6/14/1994, 6/15/1994)
2 Juan Rincon (4/27/2004, 4/28/2004)
2 Elias Sosa (7/15/1978, 7/16/1978)

Longest drought between wins

4752 Mike Morgan (5/3/1986-5/8/1999)
4604 Rich Gossage (9/20/1978[g2]-4/30/1991)
4127 Julian Tavarez (6/4/1995-9/22/2006)
3996 Doug Drabek (9/11/1986[g1]-8/21/1997)
3602 Mark Guthrie (9/14/1989-7/27/1999)
3579 Rick Sutcliffe (8/17/1982[g2]-6/5/1992)
3535 Nolan Ryan (8/18/1979-4/23/1989)
3423 Al Leiter (4/14/1988-8/29/1997)
3402 Kevin Brown (5/5/1995-8/28/2004)
3317 Dennis Martinez (4/21/1985-5/22/1994)

Includes all games played between 1977 and 2007.
The information used here was obtained free of charge from and is copyrighted by Retrosheet. Interested parties may contact Retrosheet at "www.retrosheet.org".