| ANA | ARI | ATL | BAL | BOS | CHA | CHN | CIN | CLE | COL | DET | FLO | HOU | KCA | LAN |
| MIL | MIN | NYA | NYN | OAK | PHI | PIT | SDN | SEA | SFN | SLN | TBA | TEX | TOR | WAS |
| Carl Crawford 4 | 3/31/2003, 3-run home run vs Chad Fox, BOS, 6-4 7/4/2003, 3-run home run vs Billy Koch, CHI, 4-3 8/18/2006, 2-run single vs Jason Davis, CLE, 6-5 7/30/2007, home run vs Brian Wolfe, TOR, 5-4 (11) |
| John Flaherty 4 | 8/9/1998, double vs Paul Shuey, CLE, 2-1 8/20/1999, hit by pitch vs Scott Service, KC, 5-4 8/13/2000, 3-run home run vs Bob Howry, CHI, 5-3 8/12/2001, home run vs LaTroy Hawkins, MIN, 4-3 (12) |
| Travis Lee 4 | 4/8/2003, single vs Buddy Groom, BAL, 8-7 (10) 8/5/2003, single vs Juan Acevedo, TOR, 5-4 (10) 8/13/2003, double vs B.J. Ryan, BAL, 6-5 (10) 9/11/2005, fielder's choice vs Scott Schoeneweis, TOR, 6-5 (11) |
| Fred McGriff 4 | 7/20/1999, sacrifice fly vs Steve Schrenk, PHI NL, 5-4 (13) 6/14/2000, 2-run home run vs Troy Percival, ANA, 3-2 9/26/2000, single vs Mike Stanton, NY, 2-1 10/1/2000, pinch groundout vs Rich Croushore, BOS, 3-2 (10) |
| Miguel Cairo 3 | 6/16/1998, double vs Randy Myers, TOR, 4-3 7/14/1998, single vs Carlos Reyes, BOS, 5-4 8/5/2000, walk vs Mike Trombley, BAL, 5-4 (10) |
| Gabe Gross 3 | 5/13/2008, single vs Mariano Rivera, NY, 2-1 (11) 6/1/2008, home run vs Matt Thornton, CHI, 4-3 (10) 6/21/2008, pinch 2-run double vs Doug Brocail, HOU NL, 4-3 |
| Dioner Navarro 3 | 5/2/2007, pinch fielder's choice vs Matt Guerrier, MIN, 4-3 (10) 9/25/2007, home run vs Jeff Karstens, NY, 7-6 (10) 9/16/2008, single vs Justin Masterson, BOS, 2-1 |
| Greg Vaughn 3 | 4/13/2000, single vs Tanyon Sturtze, CHI, 6-5 (12) 5/4/2000, home run vs Jeff Zimmerman, TEX, 8-7 (11) 5/30/2002, double vs Chad Bradford, OAK, 4-3 (13) |
| Jonny Gomes 2 | 7/9/2005, 2-run home run vs Troy Percival, DET, 5-4 8/16/2005, walk vs Scott Proctor, NY, 4-3 (11) |
| Ben Grieve 2 | 4/14/2002, single vs Pasqual Coco, TOR, 5-4 (10) 7/13/2002, single vs John Halama, SEA, 4-3 (10) |
| Brendan Harris 2 | 5/5/2007, single vs Jay Marshall, OAK, 3-2 (12) 5/15/2007, single vs Scott Feldman, TEX, 4-3 (10) |
| Aubrey Huff 2 | 7/25/2005, double vs Curt Schilling, BOS, 4-3 (10) 5/19/2006, home run vs Yusmeiro Petit, FLA NL, 5-4 (10) |
| Russ Johnson 2 | 6/15/2000, single vs Shigetoshi Hasegawa, ANA, 2-1 7/6/2001, single vs Ricky Bones, FLA NL, 5-4 (11) |
| Evan Longoria 2 | 5/9/2008, 2-run home run vs Justin Speier, ANA, 2-0 5/25/2008, double vs George Sherrill, BAL, 5-4 |
| Julio Lugo 2 | 8/7/2003, single vs Mike MacDougal, KC, 3-2 6/13/2004, single vs Shawn Chacon, COL NL, 3-2 |
| Carlos Pena 2 | 8/3/2008, walk vs Fernando Rodney, DET, 6-5 (10) 8/6/2008, 3-run home run vs Masahide Kobayashi, CLE, 10-7 |
| Eduardo Perez 2 | 4/9/2004, pinch single vs John Parrish, BAL, 4-3 (10) 4/22/2005, pinch home run vs Alan Embree, BOS, 5-4 |
| Andy Sheets 2 | 8/15/2002, 3-run home run vs Mark Wohlers, CLE, 4-3 9/19/2002, single vs Sterling Hitchcock, NY, 3-2 (10) |
| Bob Smith 2 | 4/13/1998, home run vs Mike Trombley, MIN, 13-12 (14) 8/11/1998, single vs Armando Benitez, BAL, 2-1 |
| B.J. Upton 2 | 4/6/2007, single vs B.J. Ryan, TOR, 6-5 9/8/2007, pinch 2-run home run vs Jeremy Accardo, TOR, 5-4 |
| Gerald Williams 2 | 8/1/2000, 2-run single vs Bob Wickman, CLE, 6-5 5/27/2001, single vs Al Levine, ANA, 4-3 (10) |
| Randy Winn 2 | 4/3/2002, single vs Jeff Farnsworth, DET, 2-1 (12) 5/11/2002, 3-run home run vs Jorge Julio, BAL, 6-4 |
| Brent Abernathy | 6/30/2002, single vs Vladimir Nunez, FLA NL, 6-5 (12) |
| Marlon Anderson | 7/3/2003, single vs Mike Timlin, BOS, 6-5 (10) |
| Rocco Baldelli | 8/30/2008, double vs Rocky Cherry, BAL, 10-9 |
| Geoff Blum | 9/25/2004, sacrifice fly vs Miguel Batista, TOR, 6-5 |
| Russell Branyan | 5/20/2006, 2-run home run vs Logan Kensing, FLA NL, 4-3 |
| Jorge Cantu | 5/10/2005, home run vs Shingo Takatsu, CHI, 7-6 |
| Steve Cox | 6/8/2002, single vs Alan Embree, SD NL, 3-2 (10) |
| Jose Cruz | 6/9/2004, single vs Tyler Walker, SF NL, 4-3 (10) |
| Elijah Dukes | 5/28/2007, 2-run single vs Todd Jones, DET, 6-5 |
| Cliff Floyd | 5/30/2008, home run vs Scott Linebrink, CHI, 2-1 |
| Nick Green | 4/8/2005, single vs Juan Cruz, OAK, 3-2 (10) |
| Jose Guillen | 8/9/2000, error vs LaTroy Hawkins, MIN, 5-4 (10) |
| Joel Guzman | 8/19/2007, single vs Rafael Perez, CLE, 4-3 (12) |
| Nathan Haynes | 4/25/2008, single vs Mike Timlin, BOS, 5-4 (11) |
| Al Martin | 4/5/2003, single vs Antonio Osuna, NY, 6-5 |
| Tino Martinez | 5/23/2004, single vs David Riske, CLE, 5-4 (10) |
| Greg Norton | 8/6/2006, home run vs Julian Tavarez, BOS, 7-6 (10) |
| Rey Sanchez | 6/11/2004, home run vs Shawn Chacon, COL NL, 8-7 (10) |
| Jared Sandberg | 8/11/2003, pinch double vs B.J. Ryan, BAL, 4-3 |
| Kevin Stocker | 5/12/1998, 2-run home run vs Michael Jackson, CLE, 6-5 (14) |
| Bubba Trammell | 4/22/2000, pinch 2-run home run vs Kent Mercker, ANA, 11-9 (10) |
| Jason Tyner | 8/22/2001, single vs B.J. Ryan, BAL, 11-10 |
| Ty Wigginton | 9/1/2006, pinch single vs Eric O'Flaherty, SEA, 2-1 |
| Delmon Young | 5/17/2007, 2-run home run vs Willie Eyre, TEX, 8-6 (10) |
| No RBI 3 | 6/7/1998, Mike Kelly scored on E3 by Ryan McGuire vs MON NL, 4-3 (11) 7/1/2003, Rocco Baldelli scored on E1 by Brandon Lyon vs BOS, 4-3 (11) 8/6/2004, Carl Crawford scored on E6 by Jose Lopez vs SEA, 2-1 (10) |